PC.47.2361Derived display label; distinct project name not provided in RFP Annexure ICRequires Attention

HRIDAY - Rashtriya Gramin Vikas Nidhi

Rashtriya Gramin Vikas Nidhi · Sikkim · Item X. Rural Development Projects

Period · To be confirmed

Schedule VII · Item X. Rural Development Projects

Design tier · D

Beneficiary target

2,500

Reached 2,200

RFP prescribed

200

+35 enhancement

Planned intervention

235

Completed 226

Sample achievement

96%

Output achievement

77%

Outcome achievement

60%

Sustainability

51%

Comparison completed

Not in intervention denominator

FGDs / KIIs (min)

2 / 3

Assets verified

0 verified

CSR investment

N/A — verified financial data not supplied

Cost per beneficiary

N/A

Target vs actual (% indicators)

Synthetic actuals with 95% CI bounds

OECD-DAC assessment (synthetic /5)

Results (all indicators)

Indicator	Layer	Unit	Target	Actual	CI	Quality	Grade
Households accessing improved services	Output	count	100	72	1–1	Quality cleared	C
Water and sanitation functionality	Output	%	80	60	1–1	Quality cleared	C
Irrigation coverage	Outcome	%	80	48	1–1	Quality cleared	C
Crop intensity	Outcome	%	80	50	1–1	Quality cleared	C
Household income change	Outcome	INR	17,751	11,538	1–1	Quality cleared	C

Qualitative evidence (6)

FGDSynthetic stakeholder group· Access, outcomes and sustainabilityC
"Illustrative evidence pattern aligned with aggregate synthetic results."
FGDSynthetic stakeholder group· Access, outcomes and sustainabilityC
"Illustrative evidence pattern aligned with aggregate synthetic results."
KIISynthetic stakeholder group· Access, outcomes and sustainabilityC
"Illustrative evidence pattern aligned with aggregate synthetic results."
KIISynthetic stakeholder group· Access, outcomes and sustainabilityC
"Illustrative evidence pattern aligned with aggregate synthetic results."
KIISynthetic stakeholder group· Access, outcomes and sustainabilityC
"Illustrative evidence pattern aligned with aggregate synthetic results."
Project caseletSynthetic stakeholder group· Access, outcomes and sustainabilityC
"Illustrative evidence pattern aligned with aggregate synthetic results."
Deviant / negative case

Assets (2)

Programme-relevant infrastructure / equipment
Sikkim · Gyalshing
Verified - synthetic
Func 95%
Programme-relevant infrastructure / equipment
Sikkim · Gyalshing
Verified - synthetic
Func 93%

Respondent composition (aggregated)

226 synthetic respondents · quality-cleared 226

gender

Non-binary / prefer not to say33%
Men35%
Women32%

social Group

SC19%
Not reported17%
ST22%
OBC19%
General23%

pwd

No96%
Yes4%

rural Urban

Rural100%

Programme indicators referenced (12)

HRID-01Households accessing improved services · Output
HRID-02Water and sanitation functionality · Output
HRID-03Irrigation coverage · Outcome
HRID-04Crop intensity · Outcome
HRID-05Household income change · Outcome
HRID-06Livelihood diversification · Outcome
HRID-07School attendance · Outcome
HRID-08Health-service utilisation · Outcome
HRID-09Community-institution functionality · Outcome
HRID-10Infrastructure functionality · Outcome
HRID-11Community contribution · Sustainability/Impact
HRID-12Sustainability readiness · Sustainability/Impact

Recommendation for the Board

High0-6 monthsOwner · LIC HFL CSR + implementation partnerC

Redesign: Protect successful delivery elements and address the weakest implementation condition before the next funding cycle.

Finding: Outcome achievement is 60% with sustainability readiness at 51%.

Condition: Subject to validation with actual assessment evidence and management response